February 27, 2017
By
Karolina Ramqvist
I’m supposed to be writing a speech about my new novel,
The White City.
It’s a March morning, no sun. I’m standing by my secretary desk. I’ve
shut the doors to the rest of the apartment and have been on the verge
of sitting down to begin, but each time I tried someone called for me:
my husband, my son, or one of my daughters. I can still hear them out in
the hall.
It’s impossible to speak to someone about a book one has written. I’m
supposed to be writing, but this is the only sentence inside me. There
are mere days before the book comes out. A number of so-called “author
appearances” have been scheduled at bookstores and libraries around the
country.
I have to figure out what to say—draft a talk about this novel
that I can give not once but repeatedly. It’s paralyzing. I can barely
bring myself to make even this tiny movement: my fingers tapping the
keys as I write this text.
The kids are making noise in the hall again; the front door slams
behind them. Silence. I breathe through my nose and think of the
meditation techniques I should be practicing.
I think about what
Virginia Woolf said in her speech before the National Society for
Women’s Service in London in January 1931: that all the great women
novelists in England in the 1800s did not have children. Those words
strike me occasionally.
I’ve written talks like this before; I’ve often agonized over the
notion of having to speak about a book, especially before hardly anyone
outside of the book business has had a chance to read it.
To hold a
talk, one could say, instead of the book. (I can’t get away
from the fact that this is how it feels.) A talk that will never cover
everything. How am I supposed to do that? Who am I even to do that? This
attitude has been interpreted as stage fright or a desire to keep a low
profile, but what frightens me isn’t the stage or the public eye but
the risk of
destroying what I understand the novel to be, that which is
still open and not-yet-realized, as it must be for the reader.
When a book has just been published, the author is asked many
questions. It’s usually difficult to respond, and there might not be any
answers. One of the most common questions—and yet it always blindsides
me—is “Why do you write?” When I was young I spent a lot of time trying
to answer that question, but however I tried I couldn’t come up with an
answer that I knew to be true.
It made me feel lousy, like someone who’d
never be a writer because I didn’t even know why I wanted to be one.
My image of the writer was the early Romantic idea of the genius who
through divine inspiration expressed their unique self in their works
and thereby said something universal about existence. The fact that this
idea didn’t allow for a girl to be a genius filled me with deep sorrow.
As I got older, I started to think that maybe the genius also couldn’t
be a woman with children. I had begun to write, and my writing was
already problematic to those in my immediate circle, a threat and a
disappointment, an attempt to shape my life around my fears and my
inability to participate in it. I didn’t have children then, but I had
boyfriends and friends, and countless demands were implicit to the
questions they posed.
Why do you have to go away to write, why can’t you
write here, why do you have to write?
Back then, I wasn’t surrounded by other people who wrote, and I
wasn’t really surrounded by people who read, and my writing couldn’t
have been considered work because the payment wasn’t commensurate with
my efforts and the time it took. (I mean, it still isn’t, but nowadays
that isn’t as clear.)
Reading Virginia Woolf at the time, I didn’t see
the glaring similarities between me and the women from the past about
whom she was writing, who started writing because pen and paper were
easy to get a hold of and writing was an activity that could be done
discreetly. But later, when I got to know other women writers who tried
to live with men—men, I should add, who didn’t share their values—I
understood that I’d never been alone in being called sick because I’d
rather write than live with and make love with them. These men hated
that we wrote. They hated how the writing took us, hated it for its
ability to bear witness to the world and for the fact that it would
remain long after they themselves were gone.
I always wanted to be an author, but I also wanted to have children.
How those two things fit together is another common question, and I’d
wondered about it myself. How would that be possible?
In equality-minded
Sweden, it’s a given that women shouldn’t have to choose between work
and starting a family, but I saw children as a potential threat to my
writing. And motherhood with its demands is really a sort of antithesis
to being a writer. But many women also live with the idea of being
perpetually available to their men, and when I think about it now, it’s
so clear that children were never the hurdle for writing—men were. I
could only start writing books once I stopped making myself available to
a man’s many ever-changing needs. But I can’t include this in a talk or
make this my answer to how I became an author.
*
An author appearance is a meeting between the author and the readers
who share time and a space and in this way it differs from our usual
meeting, the one in which the reader sits alone with the text and
completes it by reading. I like our in-person meeting best when it
reminds me of the latter. But this latter meeting can occur when we’re
in the same room, too, for instance during a Q&A in an auditorium
when a member of the audience shares his reading of the novel in a way
that allows us to glimpse our usual space of encounter: the true space
of reading. I like when this happens; experiencing the closeness between
strangers that arises when we recall the fellowship to which we are
accustomed, but can’t achieve as long as we are in the same room
speaking to each other.
It’s impossible to speak to someone about a book one has written. Marguerite Duras wrote this sentence in her penultimate book Writing.
She writes that authors are contradictory and utterly incomprehensible
and that “a book is the unknown, it’s the night, it’s closed off, and
that’s that.” Until this novel, which I’m now supposed to “say”
something about, all of my books were texts that I’d borne a long time.
They sat inside me as if in storage or ran parallel to each other like
long threads, in constant conversation about what should be written and
how. This novel came to be in a completely different way.
*
It was the summer of 2012. I had just finished my third novel,
Alltings början (
The Beginning of Everything),
my husband and I had gone out to our summer cottage with the children,
and I wasn’t supposed to be writing. I was only meant to do interviews
and be on vacation. The publisher’s publicity department had let me know
that there seemed to be an early interest in the book. This delighted
me, of course. Not only that, I’d received a few advances from foreign
publishers, my youngest daughter was to start pre-school in the fall,
I
had a grant, and would be able to start working on something new.
Finding the time to write no longer felt impossible. I should have
been happy. The novel was to come out in August, a little more than
three years since the last one, which corresponded to the idea of a real
author’s rate of production.
Now and then, I walked around outside with
the phone pressed to my ear answering journalists’ questions about the
book, and I tried to say things that would be compelling and relevant
and make it seem read-worthy. (Write-worthy?) Photographers drove out to
the cottage to take pictures, I had brought lipstick with me and a
blazer that I never otherwise had there and I stood in places around the
garden and up by the bilberry sprigs in the forest and once in the
middle of a lake atop a very leaky old wooden trampoline.
And in the same way that I put on the blazer, I dressed myself up in
the role of the author, perpetually ready to speak about my book. I
wasn’t supposed to be writing that summer, I was supposed to be having
time off, going to the beach with the children, playing with them and
cooking food and taking walks in the forest, and being available for the
marketing of the book. That’s how the authorial split appeared for me. I
had read about it and heard other writers discuss it, but now for the
first time I could feel it. I had become the writer, but who was this
writer? It cut through me with full force, the cleft that characterizes
what we call the writing profession, and which has become so obvious it
can be elusive.
In one of the Empson Lectures in Negotiating with the Dead: A Writer on Writing, Margaret
Atwood reminds us of the epigram that she keeps on her bulletin board,
one that usually brings me as much comfort as it seems to amuse my
audience: Wanting to meet an author because you like their work is like wanting to meet a duck because you like pâté.
Atwood describes the cleft as a dividing line between the person who
eats cereal at breakfast and drives off to have their car washed and the
other much more articulate shadow-being who lives in the same body and
“when no one is looking, takes it over and uses it to commit the actual
writing.”
But the split that opened up in me that summer was between
these two beings and the writer with a capital W, who appears when the
writing is done. The duck, if you will.
If the writer-genius I once idealized was substantial and authentic,
then the actual writer was a whole set of personalities that were
constantly circling each other. The role of the writer is often not
considered a “role” because performing as a writer is close to hand. The
one who writes sits alone with her text and works hour after hour, year
after year, alone with the words, searching for the word inside the
word and the shine that will arise from them.
It’s a solitary act, like
reading, and that, like reading, might lead to a book. It’s difficult
work that also isn’t really work, neither a part of working life or the
market economy. But the question is whether the writer with a capital W,
her body and life and experiences, have become more in demand than what
she has written.
I became a writer in other’s eyes that summer and also a Writer. A
person who appears on the covers of magazines, on TV-sofas or on stages
to talk about the book she has written, just like I’m supposed to be
preparing to do. Or like I’m tryi ng to avoid doing?
I told one of the reporters that I’ve always wanted to write about
what isn’t brought to the fore. That which is hidden. It was a statement
I was able to make without feeling that I’d have to take it back in the
next sentence or object to later. I had a hard time summarizing my
authorship in the ways that I was invited to do in interviews—I
understood, in spite of it all, that I was to think of it as an
invitation—but with some reluctance
I could see how the books were
creating their own kingdom. They appeared, among other ways, in relation
to each other.
When my novel
Flickvännen (
The Girlfriend)
came out in 2009, I was often asked if I was going to write a sequel.
The question seemed related to a question asked of many Scandinavian
novelists—if they might not be planning on writing a crime novel—and
each time I answered that no, I absolutely was not. The idea was alien
to me;
I didn’t understand the point. I was also asked about my personal
experience of life with a gangster and what it was like to wait at home
for him to come back from a job, like the main character Karin.
As if
what I had written were a product of my life rather than a literary
work. For instance, a TV producer called me several times in hopes of
having me on his show to talk about what it’s like for those women. I
said that I couldn’t, I could only speak on behalf of the protagonist in
The Girlfriend. What I had written was a novel, it was
fiction. On the other end of the line, the producer fell silent. “But,”
he said eventually, “how else could you know that this is how it
happened?”
This fixation on reality can be disheartening for a writer, but you
could also look at it like this: it’s not that reality is so dominant,
novels are. It’s the novel that perforates reality, and not the other
way around. At the same time, it’s also a way of talking about—and
with—the Writer. A number of journalists who called that summer also
really wanted to come out to the cabin. One couldn’t possibly do the
authorship justice unless one sat down with the writer and talked, they
said. But why would that make it possible? I am not my novel. I can only
do it injustice.
The more I tried to talk about my book, the more often I was struck
by the impossibility of doing precisely that (an impossibility that
differed from writing’s many impossibilities), the more irritated I grew
with the Writer in me who insisted on trying (even though I knew she
had her reasons).
But it was also something else.
Was this a new way of talking about literature? In past interviews, The Girlfriend
was called a “successful novel”, and I was called a “successful
author.” The focus wasn’t only on the writer as a person, but the writer
as a successful person. A big magazine article no longer seemed able to
be about a writer’s books because they were good, they also had to have
caught the attention of the media and be liked by many.
This could be
understood as a consequence of the changing conditions of cultural
journalism and literary criticism, but also as the writer as a character
being pulled into the neoliberal narrative of individual strength and
independence, which has become the media-society’s big story and that
lends itself, as literature does, to being about what it means to be
human, but in this story weakness and ambivalence are only addressed in
order to highlight strength and certitude. It was a lie that felt new
and became particularly ridiculous when applied to the writer.
So I did the only straightforward thing. I started to write even
though I wasn’t supposed to. Even though the point was for me to have
“free time” and only do some interviews. I started writing because
writing is something I can’t help but do, but also because I thought
that it would save me from the Writer, save me from the role of the
author and the human ideal that was beginning to flow into me like
undrinkable water. It was also flowing into the person who was adjacent
to writing and into the one-who-writes, who for all she knew about
hardship and impossibility should have known to build a dam to keep the
water out.
Right then I wanted to write something that wouldn’t be published,
something for which I would never stand on a stage or a leaky old wooden
trampoline in the middle of a lake, never try to talk about, never try
to
say. Because another recurring question is of course “What
do you want to say with this book?” And the answer: “I don’t want to say
anything; I wanted to write what it says in the book exactly as it is
written there.”
And in the same way that I’d long had a store of books inside me to
write, there was one I was never going to write. So I picked that one. I
started writing the sequel to
The Girlfriend, which in that
moment I believed would never be published. I reached for that story as
though it were a rope tossed to me in cold water, and it became
something to hold on to so I could get back to what I wanted. When I
stepped into Karin’s house again, she was still there, different to the
person I had left behind in
The Girlfriend. Her worst fears had
come to pass—everything that everyone, those closest to her, but also
the reader with a voice of reason, and me with mine, had warned her
about.
What we expect to happen to girls who get involved with
gangsters. She lost everything. I was asked if I did this to punish her.
*
For the one who writes, the writer is far away. The writer is
expected to have answers, the one who writes is dedicated to writing and
sitting alone with questions. It’s a cleft that runs between the quick
and the slow. The profitable and unprofitable. What everyone is waiting
for and what no one is asking for. What wants to come out and that which
shirks.
To write is to turn to face the world while turning away from
it.
Like the writer, readers come later, when the writing is done. The
book materializes in the reader’s hands, in her gaze. Letter by letter,
word by word, it carved out a space inside me and through my body, it
emerges in the space inside her. The reader can point out what the
writer has forgotten or didn’t realize was in the book, perhaps
something that provided the first impulse to write it and that belongs
to our shared world. And in her reading, she creates the text, but only
through reading the book can the reader have it and only through writing
it, exactly as it is written, can I “say” what I want to say with it.
We can’t get around the solitary and unnecessary act of all these words.
Of course the question comes up again. Why do you write? But to whom
do I owe the answer? There is no answer, and I probably knew that all
along, but maybe I didn’t dare say it until now: I write to write.
Maybe I didn’t dare say this before I became a writer. But as I write
this now, I’m overcome with the feeling that there’s something improper
about it, in how I started writing just to be the one who writes,
giving thought to nothing but the writing. The Writer’s logic is so
strong that it makes me disqualify what my own writing knows—and what I
know deep down—
is the greatest freedom. The real work of a writer.
Translated from the Swedish by Saskia Vogel.
If the writer-genius I once idealized was substantial and authentic,
then the actual writer was a whole set of personalities that were
constantly circling each other.
The role of the writer is often not
considered a “role” because performing as a writer is close to hand. The
one who writes sits alone with her text and works hour after hour, year
after year, alone with the words, searching for the word inside the
word and the shine that will arise from them. It’s a solitary act, like
reading, and that, like reading, might lead to a book. It’s difficult
work that also isn’t really work, neither a part of working life or the
market economy. But the question is whether the writer with a capital W,
her body and
life and experiences, have become more in demand than what
she has written.
I told one of the reporters that I’ve always wanted to write about what
isn’t brought to the fore. That which is hidden. It was a statement I
was able to make without feeling that I’d have to take it back in the
next sentence or object to later. I had a hard time summarizing my
authorship in the ways that I was invited to do in interviews—I
understood, in spite of it all, that I was to think of it as an
invitation—but with some reluctance
I could see how the books were
creating their own kingdom. They appeared, among other ways, in relation
to each other.
This fixation on reality can be disheartening for a writer, but you
could also look at it like this: it’s not that reality is so dominant,
novels are. It’s the novel that perforates reality, and not the other
way around. At the same time, it’s also a way of talking about—and
with—the Writer. A number of journalists who called that summer also
really wanted to come out to the cabin. One couldn’t possibly do the
authorship justice unless one sat down with the writer and talked, they
said. But why would that make it possible? I am not my novel. I can only
do it injustice.